Oh god, Le Chuck... Sounds like you met the Morbid Deviants, or maybe a group of TuChucks.. Where was this, just out of curiosity? Unfortuantely, we do tend to attract some of the more "fringe" elements of society. But overall, it's a great organization. Like I said, I've been in for nearly 30 years. My kids have been raised in the society. Honor and Chivalry are cool things. Not to mention the sheer number of skills you pick up... Back when I played Everquest I used to complain a lot about the crafting systems since I KNEW how to smith, sew, cook, fletch, etc...
And the fighting. Yes, it's a romanticized system. Yes, we use sticks. It is, however, full speed and full contact. Nothing is cooler than walking out onto the field at a large event in your armor, clutching your sword. Looking across the field and seeing the opposing army of 500+ fighters and thinking, "They all want to kill me... Better kill them first!"