See the problem here is a difference of opinion. I am aware Duke was supposed to be cheesy. It did NOT succeed though. It's "humor" fell flat on the floor 90% of the time. Doom is Duke's father, no Duke without doom.. no fps without doom and therefore doom can NEVER be overrated.
Yeah no one liked duke*, its not like they sold a ---steaming pile of meadow muffin--- ton of games, made expansion packs, some PSX sequels,etc. Glad you brought up doom, cause ---steaming pile of meadow muffin---, there wouldnt be a Wolfenstein 3D without DooM. All joking aside, I think Quake is really started moving the FPS genre. 3D environments and 3D enemies, instead of flat 2D (cardboard standee) enemies
*It was named #37 overall among the "150 Best Games of All Time" by Computer Gaming World Magazine (15th Anniversary Issue--November 1996);
It was voted #13 overall in PCGamer Magazine's Readers All-Time Top 50 Games Poll (April 2000 issue);
The editors of PC Gamer ranked it #12 in the Top 50 Games of all time, in their October 2001 issue, citing the game's humor and pop-culture references;
It was ranked #15 in the 50 Best Games of All Time list published by PC Gamer Magazine in its April 2005 issue.