first of all digital music is still heard in it's analog form, it's not like we hear a bunch of high pitched noise that we convert to music in our brains.
that being said, 128kbps mp3s sure do have that vintage 1996 sound too them

Rooms full of Arcade machines and vinyl albums have their good and bad qualities, Mame cabinets and hard drives full of mp3's do too, the difference is you don't have to be rich and spend a fortune plus dedicate half your life to a have mame cabinet or a hard drive full of mp3s.
Not to say that dedicating a lot of time money and energy into something you love isn't worthwhile, it's just that most people wouldn't go to such extremes when amazing alternatives are available.