Quarterback
John Elway's Team Quarterback
All American Football (rev E)
TouchDown Fever
TouchDown Fever 2
Note these games used special controllers. The first three (and clones) used a "SpringStick" aka a "football kicker stick"; an analog joystick that sprung all the way up to control strength of passes and kicks. The later two (and clone) used optical rotary joysticks (to control direction of pass & kick, I guess). So game play might not be as good as original (depending on you CP).
If you want to go old school, check out Atari Football (X's and O's). This actually was a vertical
cocktail with two trackballs (4 for the 4player version), and there is no AI; both players have to be manned, and it's best played with trackballs. You'll have to remap player 2 upside down to work on your upright, too. Maybe not right, but maybe worth a look.
If you want to screw with some people, Tehkan World Cup is a good game (but "soccer" to us americans).
