Let me first say again:
In no way am I saying the way I wired things is the ONLY way to do things. It is however one way to do things. Obviously there are a bevy of great choices out there for parts too.
First, I thank you for your feedback. You have some points, but have some things mistaken. Let me comment below on your feedback.
- The coin door lights, the marquee lights, the power for those can all be harvested from a PC's PSU. As such, there is no need to have an arcade switching power supply if what you are building is strictly for MAME
This is true enough. But I'm a cautious man. I don't have fancy power supplies, just normal cheap ones that comes with the PC case. Anyway, yes, you can absolutely use a PC's PSU. I just personally prefer not to. Just a preference thing, no biggy. Even if I did use the PC's power supply, I would still personally use barrier strips. I like it, and think it's cleaner.
Your next comment.
- I don't see anywhere you are wiring up a monitor. I am going to conclude that this MAME build is strictly for an LCD-based cab and you are simply plugging the monitor into a smart power strip. If so, I can see how you left this out as it is not necessary
- which leads to the next statement, if someone was looking for this to build a CRT based cab, they would have to look elsewhere for a beginner's guide
I patently disagree with this statement. This guide is independent of what monitor you choose to use. Whether you have a CRT, LCD, HDTV, LED, whatever else, it doesn't matter. You can configure the video settings yourself. Yes, it's true the monitor isn't connected with a cable or "wire" technically, but I don't have to tell you how to hook it up to your PC. I have built now seven MAME machines and restored a few arcade machines. The few of my own shown in my signature do have CRTs but I have built others using all the above mentioned monitor types and it's all the same. What monitor you use does not change how you wire up a GPWiz, or a LEDWiz. These things are universal and therefore it's my opinion that this guide is still very useful for a beginner's starting point for anyone.
Your next comment:
- This is preference, but I would left the smart power strip out and power every non-light device off the power distribution terminals (PC and monitor). Then switch off the cab with some AC power switch. You'd have to set the BIOS to recover after power loss however. IMO, it's cleaner this way and I am cheap
I prefer to shut down my computers, not just kill the power to them. I find it works out better in the long run. So for me, I make my "exit" button do a shutdown in my Front End. It shuts down the computer and the smart power strip sees that and controls the rest. For me, I like that, I find it the cleanest option. But again, there's more than one way to skin a cat. So you could definitely do it your way too. Just a preference call.
even for a beginner like me, I would be asking questions even if I was building an LCD based cab. Anyhow, hope that isn't too harsh. Just honest feedback. Perhaps we can collaborate to add a CRT cab chapter, or remove the chapter with the arcade switching PSU, streamlining it more, etc. I definitely learned a thing or two with your chapters on connecting wiring.
Questions are welcomed. I'm not saying I didn't have to help my friend more on the phone or over FaceTime with questions, but I've tried to add corrections he needed into my document. But this document gave him a starting point to start to build up the knowledge, simple things like how to splice, how to crimp, etc. If you follow it literally from start to finish, it will work as it did for my friend. That said, I'm open to adding more sections. I don't think I'll remove the arcade power supply instructions as they are a valid option if you're so inclined.
Again, thank you for your feedback.