Looks like I can get my hands on some 2'x4' sheets of 5/8" particleboard, which should do the trick. The only part of my cab that'll be using this is the CP, so should hopefully be okay.
The 1" T-mold option sounds cool, but I don't really want to route out spots for all of the buttons. That, and I feel like 1/8" plexi along with 5/8" wood will probably be easier to work with.