Well, I tried soaking one of the arrows in lighter fluid overnight. It loosened up some tape but it wants to peel off ink, too. I'm probably just ignoring this whole thing until I feel compelled to spend $100 replacing something nobody will ever notice or care about.
Had a Super Bowl party yesterday, so I decided to rig this up for play.
Of course, one of my friends made it all of 15 seconds before asking "how much did this set you back?"
Played like a champ, did have to toss some emergency foam under a couple of arrows. I'll hand it to In The Groove, once I explained "red is back, blue is next" it needed very little supervision. Did get some complaints that there were too many menus and I agree but I think that software is oriented towards people that take DDR extremely seriously.
On to the next one...