Apollo, you are the one who brought me into this thread. You are the one who decided to use my CP as an example. You need to sit down and be quiet in your corner at this point. If you didn't want me in this thread, then you should have used another panel as your "example."
If you think that for some reason I need to "respect" a 23 (or is it 24) year old burger flipper who's had about as much experience building cabs/CPs as I do (which is to say virtually none) just because he has a high post count, you are sadly mistaken. Once again, we're back to the bit about giving respect to get respect.
HC comes in, claiming to be the last word on CP design and stating that everyone is wrong who disagrees with him. He refuses to give respect to anyone. There are plenty of respectful ways to approach a subject, Howard eschewed them all... and thus he gets absolutely zero respect, deserves zero respect.
To top that off, his CP (IMO) is ugly, and shows he has no aesthetic design skill what so ever. Couple that with the fact that he claims he's the self-appointed god of CP design and it's time to call BS on him. If he could produce some pictures of some amazing panels (or Cabs) that he's designed and built, then he might have a leg to stand on... but so far, from what he's shown, he's got absolutely no authority to speak about others panels, aside from the "This is my opinion, take it or leave it."
Until that point, both you, Apollo, and HC can leave me the heck alone. Don't use my CP as your "examples." Don't tell me my opinons are right or wrong. Don't tell me what I can and can not do given my experience (or lack there of). Feel free to make helpful suggestions, that's fine... but the moment you cross that line and try to make yourself out to be something more than you are, I'll be happy to step up and knock you back over the line.
Now, to address the topic at hand:
You have not yet earned the right polish most of the shoes around here, much less give your opinion on what is the most efficient layout.
You are teh g00d engrish riter! I didn't give my opinion on what the most efficient layout is... and you shouldn't either. Neither you nor I have any qualifications to give such an opinion. Produce something that provides evidence that you are capable of understanding what an efficient design is, and I will accept your opinions as valid.
I find it odd that since my panel is so crappy the only two things you can find fault with it are the buttons and the fact that I used luscid's design for inspiration, which has absolutely nothing to do with control panel layouts. Of course, you are a newb so you probably don't know what a true luscid cab looks like.
That's not the only thing I found fault with. I find it ironic that the only arguements you can bring against my critique of your panel is the point of the buttons and my pointing out that you based it off Lucids designs... Which, if you cared to actually read and comprehend my post(s), you'd note that I pointed out the Lucid deal because YOU moaned about how other people "ripped off" designs. The ONE and ONLY reason I brought this up was because you did it yourself.
As for the buttons, that was a topic I touched on. They are ugly. They are Wack-a-mole. But, I also touched on the topic of all that extra space you have. You have this huge slab of wood and nothing on it. It's ugly, plain and simple. End of story. No arguement. Get your facts straight before you *try* to respond to me. So far, I've seen absolutely nothing from you that would run anyone off, just a big, whiney child who thinks he knows everything. It's no skin off my nose if you want to flail around and throw a tantrum because the adults have slapped you back into place. Get over it, your panel looks wretched, move on and build another one.
In other words you have nothing to complain about because my panels are just as clean and nice as I say they are.
Once again, you seem to misunderstand me (intentionally, I hope) - I didn't say they wern't clean, and "nice" is subjective. I said they were ugly, and all that extra space was pointless. They are very clean (I would say austaire actually) - and I don't think they are nice at all. But then again, that's my opinion, if you like it, great. Go play on it, I couldn't care less. I'm not forced to play on your panel, and I would never tell you how to build a panel. I would offer my advice if you asked me, but since you haven't, I wouldn't presume to give it to you.