Ok before I get flamed for using Kinkos please read the entire post

I did some color changing on the fusion artwork to match my green t-molding and going with an all black button setup. I had my marquee printed and I was very happy with the job that only cost me $13. (Yea Corporate discount!)
Now when it comes to printing the CPO it measures roughly 34"x15.5", however the center of my trackball is 8.25" from the top and I would like it to be in the center of the image. Therefore I intend on printing the CPO 36"x18" this would give me some play, and the ability to trim down after lining up.
Kinko's qouted me 5sq ft for the job, and it would cost roughly $69.95+shipping to print same size image are mamemarquee. I have a plexi cover that I will be using, however I fear that is some moisture gets under it will warp the CPO. That being said I have the choice of the following materials and prices, just would like some input.
Photo Semi-Gloss Paper = $53.42
Polly Gloss Paper = $36.21
Vinyl = Roughly $38
Let me know your opinion guys,
Squeeky