I pulled the board and booted it on the bench. Used my pocket scope to read the inputs of the suspect chip. Each strobe line is represented by 2 pins - an input and an output. The spider chip represents the input side. If everything is normal, both pins are pulsing. If the input pulses but no output, the TTL is bad. If neither pin of a matrix row pulses, no soup for you! In short, diodes had nothing to do with it.
I did go ahead and finish putting in the replacement chip and attached the battery pack. When I first turned the game back on, it was acting very weird! All kinds of stuff was acting funny. After a while, I realized the problem: I had switched out the game prom to the other board, and currently had a Pinball pool prom in the 'working board'. I rectified that problem and got back to mostly working condition. I supposed it is the addition of the battery pack, but the game does act up a bit more now. Pushing the start button too many times puts the game into service mode - as in the start button functions as the service button. The service button does nothing.
In the end, I now know that everything on the cabinet works except for the main board. I will keep an eye out for a tested 100% CPU, or just ask Santa for a repro cpu. I have played this game enough to think that I would like keeping it around for a while. I do like the playfield for the most part, and everyone who played it at the party yesterday loved it. At this point I just have to see it thru as a restored machine.