Well, Justin Z, thanks for proving my point. In all of your examples, every player on the field knows what's going to happen before it happens. Then if it happens, they know what to do next.
Even if this gross generalization were true, the human element would, by definition, make the game unpredictable, thus ruining the very basis of your argument from the start. That's the problem with absolute statements like the one you've made. They fall down logically.
Furthermore, not only do five players in the field never know what pitch is coming (2nd, short, pitcher and catcher hopefully do), but no matter how good of an eye you have, you don't know how the ball is going to come off the bat until a significant amount of time has passed. You'd better be able to figure out what's happening, and react . . . quickly. You don't know from the start.
Were baseball played by robots, you might have a point.
----------
1. Baserunning
(a) Hit and run?
(b) Double steal?
(c) Delayed steal?
-------------
You always steal if you think you're fast enough to make it.
Not a chance. You steal when you feel the situation calls for it. You're more likely to send a good runner than a poor one, true. But my college baseball team's first baseman, who's about 235 pounds and to put it plainly, is slow, had 8 stolen bases last season, which was like third on the team. Speed has far less to do with it than you want to claim it does.
--------------
2. At the plate
(a) Approach pitches aggressively?
(b) Wait for pitches and try to draw a walk?
(c) Sacrifice bunt?
(d) Drag bunt?
(e) Slash?
---------------
You can't wait out pitches if the pitcher is throwing strikes. Who cares on the rest of it? You know a batter is going to bunt before he's on the plate.
No, you can't. So your strategy has to change. You would need several cocktail napkins to cover your strategy at the plate from pitch to pitch.
Again bringing up the team I mentioned before, we had a player who would get one strike on him and then had at least ten drag bunts for singles that he executed after taking or swinging and missing the first strike. There was no way to tell if he was going to do it or not.
---------
As for defense, do you
(a) play in your corners?
(b) play at double play depth?
(c) execute a wheel play?
-----------
You go to where you think the batter might hit it, but either way, you gotta run to wherever the ball is hit if it's in your zone.
I suppose then that wide receivers don't run to where the passer has thrown the ball? That linebackers don't stop pursuing the option quarterback and start pursuing the pitch man when the ball is lateraled? That basketball players dribble away from the basket in an effort to drive in and score? That goalies move their pads out of the way of a shot puck? Your statement doesn't make sense.
Sorry, but I stand fully by what I said. There's nothing unpredictable in baseball.
Have you ever seen a team steal home?
[/quote]