i really didnt like Eternal Darkness at all, its a resident evil clone with some interesting scare tactics in it.
Basically, you go crazy as you see weird things, which make weird things happen in the game... but nothing really 'jump-out-at-you' scary, more things that would be scary in real life and dont really do anything in the game...
I got pretty tired of the four or five baddies you fight, and i thought the graphics were sub par compared to Resident Evil or Alone in the Dark: TNN
Some of the puzzles are really neat and challenging if i remember, maybe thats what people liked, I hated the story though... Just one mans opinion, always try a game for yourself (obviously)

It may sound good, but dont even LOOK at Star Fox Adventures... seriously

-mal
Def Jam Vendetta
all the Res Evil games
Super Smash Bros
Metal Gear Twin Snakes