I managed to find some rust free fenders at the junkyard, the first one was a real pain to take off (hour and a half), but the second one came off in like 10 minutes. They are (of course) a different color scheme (and are badged 6.2 Liter Diesel), but they are still a whole lot better than the ones that were on it, plus they won't be so glaring out of place once I primer them, since the truck is almost the exact same color as primer grey anyway!

I might go back and steal the rear bumper too, as it is perfect, and mine has been hit.