I loved ID4, except for the atrocious fx when the dog escapes the blast in the tunnel. Lordy that was bad. But the rest of the movie was great to me, even the Razzberry award winning speech by Bill Pullman.
Oh yeah...Randy Quaid's son in the movie was a terrible actor as well in it.
Now for another one that technically was great, but is maligned mostly by men: Titanic. Yeah, I thought it was a great movie too. Plus you had young Kate Winslet boobs. In a PG-13 movie!