The buttons would probably be fine but the leverage of someone pulling a joystick might be a little too much. I dunno about where you live, but there is a local hardware shop a mile from my house that sells 3/4 inch plexi for about 75 bucks for a 5'x5' square (I can get it any size, they cut it). Its extremely strong, though, as we use it to build subwoofers sans mdf. It's good stuff if you can get it.