This time Joy1 Left is stuck in the ON position. My control panels are swappable and I get the same result with whatever one is plugged in, so I know it's not a bad switch.
This problem did not happen after doing anything weird. It worked fine for a few days with the same panel attached. It just stopped working one morning after turning the whole system on. This weekend I'll try and bypass my quick-connect setup and directly wire in a button to Joy1 Left....and ground everything to the PC case, any every other suggestion everyone gave, although I'll have to do some reading on "hot" monitor chassis.
PC swap will be my last resort.
Oh, another thing..My cabinet had a TV in when my first 2 interfaces died. 3rd one died with the monitor installed...I don't think they were the cause. I've narrowed it down to two problem a) bizarre static problem, or b) bad PC. I don't want to think about c)...