I can see why he wants it out of his house ASAP!
Living in NY (but not a NY native) I can honestly say just about everything is over priced up here. I think a lot of people (stress- not everyone) has the mentality that if you pay more for something then it's better and worth more. Every now and then you can find a good deal on something, but most of the time people ask outrageous prices, and sadly, they usually get it.