Yeah, I remember it being not terrible either. Then I tried it a few years ago. It's really not bad if you're used to playing games in a snow storm. I also didn't feel like VHS was so bad when DVD came out, but it's damn terrible. Then again, the tapes are getting older as well.
I sometimes wonder if the more modern advancements will seem like such tremendous leaps in hindsight, even though component and dolby 5.1 are more than enough for me at the moment.