I would suggest building one.. I have a metal MyMyBox pad and they are pretty sucky, too, without substantial mods. Everyone who has tried both seem to agree that you can get better results making a DDR Homepad. You can do whatever you want that way: lights, 6 or 8 buttons, raised platform, one-piece dual setup, custom graphics, increased durability, etc.
That is if you are willing to do this for your friend :/..