Thanks for all the suggestions...
paigeoliver: I had forgot that I could use the NO contact on the microswitch as another input...but I am not sure that I would want one of those inputs to be always on. As for your modified shifter idea, does this mean that it would be spring loaded into the neutral position? A photoshop pic would be great if you have time, thanks

shmokes: I've heard you should be able to map the buttons to keys using a program such as Joy2Key (although I have never tried it). Some FE's can be controlled using a mouse, but typically the more Windows-looking ones. I'm not sure about all the ones featured on this site, but MAMEWAH cannot be controlled by mouse atm.
Beley: How would this circuit idea work?
Rocky: I see what you mean...I have found there are 3 types of shifter configs in MAME:
1) Key pressed all the time for low gear, release for high (eg Chase HQ)
2) Keypress for low, different keypress for high (eg OutRun)
3) Keypress to toggle high/low (eg Pole Position)
I suppose you have all of those covered, whereas the standard shifter would only work with type 1) I think.
My head is beginning to hurt
