I don't think you'll be real happy with one of the 1-1/2".
My suggestion, given that you are using an LCD would be to go with the 2-1/4", and make a scale version of the top of a GT Fore cab.
With the monitor laying back nearly horizontal, you solve all of your hand crashing problems.
Alternately, you could do something along the lines of the top of a Pacman cab.
Since you're not using a monitor with a neck, clearance shouldn't be a problem.