Here is what I did,
I had a professional Photographer take a picture of my Midway Coin Door.  
The Coin door itself is in good shape with just a little bit of rust on the buttons, etc.  I cleaned it up about as good as I could, and you can see a few of the imperfections in the picture, but I think it adds character!
I then took the HQ image to my local print shop, and I had three laminate options;
    1.  Photo paper, hot roll laminate, no adhesive.  Great quality, and ultimately the option I went with.   
    2.  Plain paper with a self stick back side laminate.  Nice, but the image did not have a very consistent black to it.
    3.  Photo paper with a self stick laminate.  Better, but the photo paper caused bubbles in the laminate when it went thru the machine.
I wanted the hot roll laminate, but they do not offer that with self stick. 

The image itself is 9 3/4" wide by 8" tall, so it is a little smaller than the original coin door, but that is what I ultimately wanted.
What do you think?