One game i've found that works surprisingly well is Duke Nukem - Manhattan Project.
For those of you who don't know, it's a modern return to the sidescroller roots of Duke Nukem, but it's 3D. (basically, 2.5D)
despite its 'decent' reviews, the main problem with it was that it wasn't suitable for modern gaming audiences who aren't interested in side scrollers, more 3D shooters. For us nostalgic folks who live the sidescrollers though, it's perfect. It also puts alot new cool situations into the genre, e.g. fighting a helicopter as it flies around the stage randomly attacking you.
This game just screams arcade cabinet, it's fast, it's addictive, there's lots of explosions and all bad one liners and destruction you'd expect from a Duke Nukem game. (Definately not one for the young kids...)
Might need a reasonable PC to run it though, as it isn't that old a game.

You can find a demo of it online if your interested,
http://www.dukenukemmp.com/