Hi Aaron - thanks for taking the time to reply.
Yes in most cases \\.\PHYSICALDRIVE0 is the boot drive, but not in my case.  I boot of 2 (master on the secondary IDE channel).  Anyway, the problem I have is not with which drive to exctract to.  I am absolutely sure I have that correct, verified by size and model/serial number.
So, given that I'm sure I'm extracting to the correct physical drive, can you think of any other reason the resulting drive does not work? 
FWIW, I also tried this on two different pc's, one with XP the other with Win2K, each with different phsycal drives (one was "0" the other was "1").  Same result.
Thanks again.  I really appreciate your advice.