Do you have a overlay on the CP? If so (and this will sound like a pain in the @$$), but drill, NOT HAMMER a hole for a small bolt. The problem that arrises is that (and I am sure that you are aware of this now) but since you have taken the plastic protection off of the plexi, every spec of dust on the known universe has been attracted to your it. If you drill a hole, you are directly introducing dust to the CP. Worse is that in the super tiny air layer between the CP and plexi will by stupid nature suck up some of that dust, so there will be a light dust haze around the drilled hole. Here is the pain part I was speaking about... Take all the buttons out (eek)lift the plexi to re clean it and clean the CP, then re button it.
Ok, as to the lifting. you want the CP as clean as possible, so go to the corners and come in about an inch. If you have a lip around the edge, you will need to decide to put it inside the CP box or outside. You can get a 1/4 carrage bolt and paint it black (spraypaint works great) Drill your hole. Now here is the thing about carrage bolts. they have the square insert thing that holds them steady. If you tightened your bolt using a 1/4 in . hole, the square on the carrage bolt will crack the plexi. I found a widening drill bit at Home depot. It is about 5/8 around (1/4 in shaft on the drill side) At the end it makes a cone shape, but it is notched so it will take away the surface. using light pressure, drill with the widener untill you get a width that will take the square, but not so wide as to be bigger than the carrage bolt.
Once you have all that done, clean as I mentioned above and enjoy your plexi (that is no longer going ANYWHERE).