I keep hearing about these horror stories and I don't understand them because TigerDirect does not actually offer rebates!
The rebates are all through the manufacturers.(ie. Segate, Asus, Ultra, etc).
I have bought many things through TigerDirect (most with rebates) and I have gotten every penny. Some of the more recent ones were even direct deposited for me.
TigerDirect even has a rebate guarantee program, but it requires extra effort and documentation on your part such as documenting everything and paying for delivery confirmation when you send in the rebate.
With any rebate, you MUST read everything carefully, and make sure you send in all the required information. Pay attention to expiration dates!!!!!!!! Most rebates expire.