Just remember you want to sum the AC current, not the DC current. Also, you may have to worry about about the initial draw of current which may be higher then the sums you added. This will cause you to blow your fuse everytime you flip your switch.
Personally, I would just add a surge protector for your situation.
Edit: Rayb, I always read about your project, but still get confused on what you are doing. Like this example, you are looking for a fuse rating for a JAMMA cab, but you are building a MAME cabinet. Correct?