I'm sure you'll get a lot of replies, but I really enjoy mine. I had a leaf switch joystick that started going south on me (one of the leafs broke and was intermittent).
Anyway after putting this one in my cabinet, it has perfomred very well.
I modified it to be able to switch from 4 to 8 way without having to unscrew anything.
I used R/C car shock springs and long screws so all I have to do is grab the yellow plastic piece, pull it out and slide it from one side to the other. Works like a champ.
I also took a stronger spring from another R/C shock and made the action of the joystick stronger/stiffer.