Well, it turned out that buttons 3 & 4 were actually just "turbo" versions of 1 & 2, 5 & 6 did nothing at all. Was working pretty good until something crossed up and it kept inputting button 1 over and over.....then it did nothing after that . Guess I burned up that old gamepad!
Oh well, I see how it works now so I'll just go pick up another cheap pad or stick and wire it up. (Originally I had been working with v2.41....that's why I didn't see any place to input with a gamepad)
Thanks Chris!!