I drew 24DP, 20deg pressure angle spur gears for you.
The 1" PD spur will have 24 teeth, and the 3.125" spur needs 75 teeth. Your CNC can accept DXF, right? The calculations for proper tooth profile are pretty involved to ensure proper meshing, so it would be best if you can import my DXF directly without trying to redraw it, if possible.
Good luck!!