Hey Ryan,
In order to answer you with some degree of accuracy of opinion could you clarify something?
Are you looking to switch between 4 way and 8 way often? Or are you just looking for a good 4 way only stick...
IMHO if your intention is to switch between 4 and 8 way on Supers, it's my understandind that it's cumbersome to switch around the activator bulb thingie to swithc between 8/4 way mode...
With that said, if you were using supers you could use oscar restrictor plates to switch (Again if thtat's your intention)
Have you looked at ultimarc's t-stick, and j-sticks, etc?
OF course if you just want 4 way action maybe a dedicated 4 way would be best....
Rampy