i checked some of the reviews on amazon, it seems people generally like that stick you linked but, note that some complain that the joystick is not great and also it is quite loud in operation
it seems that a lot of people who buy arcade controllers like you linked above generally seem to end up putting in sanwa parts instead (joystick and buttons)
a lot of it depends on how fussy you are I would say
(sorry if all that is not very helpful!)