Hey all, forum noob here... let me first say I am not a DIY'er as far as these arcades go, simply don't have the time with family and job right now... and I have great respect for you all who take such time and care to build your own machines. I don't mind paying for a machine that WORKS and that can be supported properly.
Let me also say this is not a post to defame the builder of my current machine, I just thought that this machine would have been more turnkey than it has been, as it cost over 3k.
So... About a year and half ago I purchased a machine. The guys over there seemed nice and what sold me at the time was they had more than just the MAME stuff included (other consoles), and I had not seen anyone else doing that (at least that I could find).
Keep in mind I didn't have much knowledge about how the emulators worked or the frontend software, etc. at the time of purchase.
So I get the machine and it won't boot. I open up the cab and see there is a flash drive stuck one of the usb ports... so it was trying to boot off of that. Removed that and it boots up. (Called them and they had said they must have forgotten to remove it before shipping, so I sent the flash drive back to them.) Then an add/remove hardware wizard shows up that I have to click off of to move forward. I have not been able to remove that or figure out why it keeps wanting to add new hardware.
Next, the coin slots didn't work... opened that up and saw none of the wires were connected. Once I figured out how to connect those, it was onto playing.
(BTW, this arcade came with no instructions on anything. In fact the guys over there said they were working on a manual or something but I have yet to see that.)
Ok, so back to playing... most of the MAME stuff worked well, but many of the console games just didn't work control wise (one only shows the bottom half of the screen when trying to play games, and it stutters a lot)... I was instructed to go into the control menus of Maximus Arcade, but that looked like global settings only, and I did not want to wreck controls for other emulators.
I did get one console to work well because I could pull up a menu in that emulator specifically, but then every few times I start a game it gives an error of loading a config file and I have to reconfigure the controls again. That usually lasts a few games, then I have to do it again.
Next, one of the joysticks came loose... opened up the controller and one of the little clips that holds the joystick had popped off... replaced that and it has been ok since.
Now, just in the last few months the arcade monitor gets very dark and discolored in on the left side and a bit on the right side, but sporadically. In addition, the PC sometimes doesn't boot right away and will cycle through several boots before XP loads. Sometimes it takes more than 10 min, but I just shut it off and that point and try again.
Yet another issue is that is more bothersome than anything is that to access the PC inside the cab you have to go through the coin slot door... there is no larger latch on the cab, which makes it impossible to access the back of the pc unless you move the cab and unscrew a large piece off...or you have the arms of plasticman.
Now, I can live with the hard-to-access cabinet and the minor issues (the usb, the coin slot etc.), but playing this thing is a CHORE because of all the software and maybe? hardware problems. Like I said, the MAME stuff works fine for the most part, it's the other stuff that has been trouble.
I have contacted the guys via email last week and haven't heard back yet. I also called a couple times but was not able to reach them.
So that gets me to the real reason for this thread. Rather than try and fix all of these issues, it appears these guys may not be the best option for someone who wants a turnkey arcade cabinet. In other words, someone who doesn't want to mess with the software often, if at all.
I need help on suggestions for a new machine at this point... from who and why? Yeah, it will hurt to drop another 2-3k after only a year and half, but I am prepared to do it if I can get a machine that just WORKS and is supported from a software standpoint. Or maybe that's not realistic give the DIY nature of this hobby?
My key wants are:
1. Solid cab and hardware
2. working software/frontend/controls
3. mame stuff plus classic consoles
4. may want an LCD vs. CRT for future proofing reasons
So after researching I found Xarcade that looks like it's been around awhile, doesn't offer much customization but that is not a big issue for me. The main issue there is it only has some MAME stuff, no console stuff.
Then I found Dream Arcades, which looks again like it's been around and has been featured in a lot of media... looks like a friendly staff and they do offer great software/game support. On the other hand, again, just MAME stuff.
And recently saw Dream Home Arcades, which by far looks like the best custom work, but appears to be a 1 man shop and while he may support customers well, you're relying on 1 guy moving forward. On the plus side, they offer a zillion games and I have heard nothing but good stuff about his support.
Are there any other solid options out there that you can share? Any other suggestions?
I really appreciate you all taking the time to read this long-winded thread (my wife only makes it past the 2nd paragraph when I talk about these things to her

) and any advice you can give.
Cheers!
