So I'm finally getting around to finishing my MAME conversion. It's been almost 8 years in the making, but now it's time to get it done. It's an original Pac-Man cabinet (long since converted to the game with the awesomest side art - Romstar's Black Tiger). The Pac-Man art is under about 17 coats of paint, and the CP is long gone.
Anyway, my problem is that I want to keep the panel at the same width as the interior of the cabinet - about 23 1/8". I had one on there that I liked and it fit, but I want to add a trackball. I'm looking for 2 players, 6 buttons each, and one trackball in the middle. Everything I look at has giant bases, and they take up nearly a third of the space of the panel. My current joysticks are (I think) Happ Competition, but I'm not sure (grabbed them in a kit from ebay 5 years ago). I've seen some layouts that manage to incorporate all of that, but can't tell what the components are underneath. Is 6 buttons overkill for the size I'm wanting to keep? I'm not so worried about depth, but ideally I'd keep it between 8 and 10".
Are there worthy controls that don't take up giant swaths of space? I'm up for switching any of it out. Thanks!