Thanks Bob. I definitely have a bad switch then and will get a replacement from the retailer I bought it from. The one switch isn't acting in an 'all or none' fashion. I also noticed on that thread where this was mentioned
"There should be no tension on the actuator from the E-clip. The E-clip should only be putting tension on the inner sleeve."
I don't see how that works? On both my super and my comp, I had to compress the actuators against the spring in order to put the e-clip on.