Happ Competition 4-way? or other Solution

[hockeyfreak186]

Hi everyone ,

I just recently dove into the world that is this wonderful hobby.  I have read a lot, but am still learning some things as I go.  I recently started a 3 sidded cocktail which can be seen here: http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php?topic=104008.0

I am trying to keep this thing on a low budget so I went and bought 4 happ competition sticks(1 for each vert side and 2 for the horizontal side) which are 8-way sticks.  I heard that for the price they aren't bad.  But in recent reading I found that people say it is a pain to play 4-way games with an 8-way stick.

I guess what i had in mind was to find if there are any type of restrictor plates for these sticks, or if I need a 4 way at all?  I really only need one 4-way for the main player vertical side.  I heard you can cut diamond shaped holes in the cp, but that's not the route I was wanting to go.  Are there even a lot of vertical games that use 8-ways that i would miss out on if i were to do that?

Another solution I had thought of was to just buy a new joystick.  And if that's the case can anyone suggest a decent 4-way or even a 4-way/8-way for a reasonable price?

Any advice, suggestions, or any help at all would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks!

[severdhed]

I believe groovygamegear.com sells 4way restrictors for happy sticks.  There are only a few sticks that are switchable from the  top of the panel...and a lot of people that have used them don't seem to like the feel of them.  If you have the money, a u360 is the best option for this.  If you want.a.dedicated 4way, the sanwa jlw is awesome.  I posted this  from my phone, so sorry for any typos.

[mmb]

I believe groovygamegear.com sells 4way restrictors for happy sticks.

The Groovy Gamer Gear 4way restrictor is for Happ Super Joysticks, not the comp that OP has.  I have a super with the restrictor plate and it's a good solution for around $13.50 +SH.

The Comp stick doesn't have the holes available to mount the restrictor plate like the Super has.


Screws into these holes


The Comp lacks that mount point and the actuator isn't compatible.

[severdhed]

ahh, i knew they made one, but i wasnt sure which happ stick it was for.  personally, i dont think you can get a better 4way stick than a sanwa JLW-TM-8.  it is switchable to 8way also but it involves loosening 4 screws and turning the restrictor plate from below.  they are awesome 4way sticks though and not too expensive. $20.90 + shipping from lizardlick.com (that price includes 1 balltop, which you have to select separately)

http://www.lizardlick.com/pages/joysticks.shtml

[hockeyfreak186]

Thank you mmb and severdhed for your suggestions!   I think the easiest solution is just to buy a new joystick, i just wanted to make sure that there wasn't a restrictor plate for the happ competition.  The u360 is a little much for my needs, but the happ super and JLW-TM-8 seem to be what im looking for.  Ill do a little research on both to see which one fits my needs better.  Thanks again!

[mmb]

The Super is cheaper and the bat handle will match your comps.

The JLW-TM-8 is a "better" joystick and has that classic ball top look for 4 way games.

[hockeyfreak186]

Yea I had thought about that.  Is the JLW-UM-8 with bat handle the same stick as the JLW-TM-8 just without the ball?  And If i bought a super, could I put my red competition shaft in place of the black super one?

[alfonzotan]

Jammaboards.com sells this 4/8-way stick for $12 plus shipping.  I have one in my panel, and it's worked fine:

http://www.jammaboards.com/store/classic-arcade-joystick-8-way-to-4-way-switchable-/prod_282.html

Be sure to completely tighten down the nut on the bottom of the stick once it's installed, otherwise the throw will be very clunky. 

[RandyT]

Jammaboards.com sells this 4/8-way stick for $12 plus shipping.  I have one in my panel, and it's worked fine:

http://www.jammaboards.com/store/classic-arcade-joystick-8-way-to-4-way-switchable-/prod_282.html

Be sure to completely tighten down the nut on the bottom of the stick once it's installed, otherwise the throw will be very clunky.  

That's not a true 4-way.  Not sure how one could even make that statement, based on the supposed switching method (flipping the actuator on a square restriction).

From the review someone left..." I keep it in 4-way all the time and it works great! The best part is you don't have to switch it back to 8-way to play those games...You can still get all the movement you need in 4-way mode! "   That's gotta make you wonder......

RandyT

[severdhed]

Yea I had thought about that.  Is the JLW-UM-8 with bat handle the same stick as the JLW-TM-8 just without the ball?  And If i bought a super, could I put my red competition shaft in place of the black super one?

the UM-8 and the TM-8 are very similar, but the shafts and tops are different.  the UM-8 is designed for the bat top and is a much thicker shaft than the one on the TM-8.  the TM-8 is designed for a ball top, but there are adapters you can use with it to install a bat top as well.  i personally would buy the TM-8 regardless of which type of top you want, that way you can change your mind later..if you get the um-8, you can only use bat tops on it.

i could be wrong, but i dont think the competition shaft will fit in a super

[Ginsu Victim]

From the review someone left..." I keep it in 4-way all the time and it works great! The best part is you don't have to switch it back to 8-way to play those games...You can still get all the movement you need in 4-way mode! "   That's gotta make you wonder......

All that did was make me laugh.

Thanks for pointing that review out.

[RandyT]

All that did was make me laugh.

I got a kick out of it too.  I think I actually have one of those sticks here, but the bottom drawing at the site is way off, which is throwing me.

If it's the one I have, flipping the restrictor on the bottom actually does cause it to rotate to the diamond shape, but it still allows for all of the switches to activate as easily as though you hadn't even bothered.  There would still be another piece required to turn it into a decent 4-way, that being a different actuator... or at least different switches.  I haven't tried changing the switches yet to see how that affects things, but the ones that come stock have non-standard actuators.  They make it a decent 8-way, but 4-way, not so much.

RandyT

[alfonzotan]

All that did was make me laugh.

I got a kick out of it too.  I think I actually have one of those sticks here, but the bottom drawing at the site is way off, which is throwing me.

If it's the one I have, flipping the restrictor on the bottom actually does cause it to rotate to the diamond shape, but it still allows for all of the switches to activate as easily as though you hadn't even bothered.  There would still be another piece required to turn it into a decent 4-way, that being a different actuator... or at least different switches.  I haven't tried changing the switches yet to see how that affects things, but the ones that come stock have non-standard actuators.  They make it a decent 8-way, but 4-way, not so much.

RandyT

That review quote is seriously goofy, but it does work properly (at least mine does) as a 4-way with the restrictor flipped.

[RandyT]

That review quote is seriously goofy, but it does work properly (at least mine does) as a 4-way with the restrictor flipped.

I think the word "properly" is being used a little subjectively.  A "proper" 4-way doesn't allow more than one switch to activate at any given time.  A tiny amount of crossover is usually acceptable as well, because the amount of time the two are engaged simultaneously is very small and usually won't affect gameplay.  If your stick has those switches with the large concave actuators on them (the ones designed for it), I think you'll find that neither of the above can be used to describe the function of it.  The diamond plate (it's hard to consider it restriction if it still allows full access to all of the switches) may help you get to the switch you are looking for, but you are still rolling through all of them in a big way to get there.  In fact, on mine when going from UP to RIGHT, the UP switch doesn't disengage until the stick is almost in it's right-most position and RIGHT engages just a very short distance out of it's up-most position.

RandyT

[darcyp]

for my cab i bought tornado terry's ms pac man stick. for $20, it is a great physically restricted 4 way and looks great too.

[Ginsu Victim]

Tornado terry's 4-way has a huge dead zone. I am not happy with mine at all. You have to press the stick pretty far before the switches engage.

[hockeyfreak186]

Well thank you all for the advice comments and suggestions! I certainly know more about joysticks now than I did before! Im still debating about what one to get, but ill research a little more before I make my decision.  Id probably like to have a true 4 way, at least on one of the vertical sides of my cab, then i can play 8 way verts on the other side. So again thank you for the disscusions and the insight!

[darcyp]

Tornado terry's 4-way has a huge dead zone. I am not happy with mine at all. You have to press the stick pretty far before the switches engage.

You do have a point. For some reason I only ever notice this on 2 way games, which are easy enough to just play with 8 ways.

[severdhed]

the JLW is a pretty short, light throw, which makes it very quick feeling.

[hockeyfreak186]

After much debate, I think im going to go with the HAPP supers with the restrictor plate.  I figure it would be better looking to keep everything HAPP with bat tops to keep the same style on the cab.  Also, its cheaper by a bit and I've read that the JLW has a short shaft and isn't ideal for 3/4" wood CPs.

[mgb]

yeah, if you did go with a JLW, you would have to modify the mounting like from top using a pacman mounting plate.
But I gotta say that I really like the JLW sticks for 4-way. alot of people also use JLFs but I think they have a sissy feel to them.
You should be fine with the super and GGGs restrictor plate

[Ginsu Victim]

yeah, if you did go with a JLW, you would have to modify the mounting like from top using a pacman mounting plate.

Why?

[DeLuSioNal29]

for my cab i bought tornado terry's ms pac man stick. for $20, it is a great physically restricted 4 way and looks great too.

+1 on this joystick.  I own 2 of them.

[jimmy2x2x]

I was looking at them, they seem like they are great value - but doesn't the extended shaft = longer throw?

[Ginsu Victim]

There are two places to attach the E-clip, meaning two lengths (wood and metal).

[Radford119]

I feel your pain on this one man. In my first build I used all 8 way sticks and found it extremely annoying to use on 4 way games (pac man / donkey kong) so much so that I didn't even want to play them. My latest build I used a Happ Ms Pacman/Galaga reproduction for a metal control panel. If you have any skill with a router this stick can be mounted flush in a 3/4 piece of wood using the metal joystick plate. I did this on mine and couldn't be happier. I will attach some pics soon of the cab and the joystick.  I debated for a long time on whether to get a Tornado Terry balltop for wood panels and was really worried about the dead area people are speaking of. It makes a difference in the feel and gameplay when you have to go an extra 1/4 of an inch to hit left or right.

[Ginsu Victim]

The dead area killed it for me. I bought two based on DeLuSioNal29's recommendation (and even had one donated to one of our competitions) and I was extremely disappointed. Glad he likes his, but I can't get past the dead zone on it.

[DeLuSioNal29]

I also forgot to mention that I also tried GGG's super joystick with the 4-way restrictor mentioned above and it didn't quite work the way I had hoped.

[severdhed]

that's why i'm telling you guys, you can't beat a JLW for a 4way stick. I have one currently bottom mounted in a 3/4" panel, it is may seem a little short, it still feels very good. there is approximately 3/4" from the panel to the bottom of the ball, and it is approximately 2" to the top of the ball.  i think i am going to use a router to top mount it when i build my new panel, but it works just fine bottom mounted.

[Ginsu Victim]

I plan on getting one for a future project. At least I've got the U360s for now.

[RandyT]

Or you could try one of these 

.

[darcyp]

Or you could try one of these 

right after i ordered from you too, would have loved to try this out. maybe soon.

[severdhed]

yeah, i just placed an order too...i dont really need another 4 way, but i might have given it a shot.  how is the spring tension, throw distance compared to some other popular sticks?  is this stick designed to be bottom mounted in a wood panel?

[mgb]

yeah, if you did go with a JLW, you would have to modify the mounting like from top using a pacman mounting plate.

Why?

The shafts are short.
I suppose you can also route them in under the control panel

[mgb]

that's why i'm telling you guys, you can't beat a JLW for a 4way stick. I have one currently bottom mounted in a 3/4" panel, it is may seem a little short, it still feels very good. there is approximately 3/4" from the panel to the bottom of the ball, and it is approximately 2" to the top of the ball.  i think i am going to use a router to top mount it when i build my new panel, but it works just fine bottom mounted.

youre right, the JLW is a great stick. I used one in someone elses 60-in-1 as strictly a 4-way and I loved it. I'm building a new control panel and I'm using pacman joystick mounts and cutting the wood of the control panel so that they are still mounted from underneath so if I need to replace them I dont have to tear up my artwork (there is a metal cover over my wood panel).

Just dont go for the JLF, they typically cost more and theyre just puny. But alot of guys like them for fighters in 8-way

[Radford119]

Here are some pics of my Happ 4-way Ms. Pacman repro stick for a metal control panel mounted in a 3/4 wood panel. I chose the metal mount version because of the short throw and short height. This is a 60-in-1 jamma scratch built cab, I made it specifically to enjoy old school 4 way gaming. So far I am really enjoying the stick. The only way I think it could get better is if it was leaf based vs. microswitch. Hope this helps you out.

[Ginsu Victim]

yeah, if you did go with a JLW, you would have to modify the mounting like from top using a pacman mounting plate.

Why?

The shafts are short.
I suppose you can also route them in under the control panel

Just confused by using a pacman mounting plate as opposed to other methods. Most people use wood panels, so the use of the pacman mounting confuses me....

[EvilNuff]

Does anyone (other than you Randy:)) have a review of the GGG true 4 way?  Specifically how does it compare to the JLW?  Did not see any in the review forum?

[Ginsu Victim]

Does anyone (other than you Randy:)) have a review of the GGG true 4 way?  Specifically how does it compare to the JLW?  Did not see any in the review forum?

It's brand new. He revealed it, I do believe, here first. I'm seriously considering ordering one today.

Edit: Just placed the order. Hopefully I'll have a review up sooner or later.

[mgb]

The shafts are short.
I suppose you can also route them in under the control panel
[/quote]

Just confused by using a pacman mounting plate as opposed to other methods. Most people use wood panels, so the use of the pacman mounting confuses me....
[/quote]

A Pacman control panel is wood with a metal overlay. The center is cut out with a metal joystick mounting plate.
Twisted quarter sells the mounts
this setup wont work for some installs but for my cp, it works because I have a metal overlay over a wood panel.
a nice thing with this setup is also that by using spacers you have a little tweak room for setting the shaft height.