What was the reason he was banned ACCORDING TO THE RULES?
I'm betting the answer lies in Post Hell, so we may never know. However, Saint vary rarely bans people, so if he was banned, you can be certain it was for a good reason.
I've lost exact count, but he has been banned, in his various incarnations, either 4 or 5 times now.
I think it is 5 ... I believe one of his accounts was reinstated after a previous banning.
That would mean Ummon has been banned as much as or more than
all others combined (that I can think of) in all the time that I have been here.
I saw a number of the events that lead to some of his bannings and they were all pretty clearcut and I know that I was thinking that he should be banned again in the first weeks of December, even though I wasn't involved in those dustups.