As Tiger-Heli said you need the Hi folder, there is a NVRAM file for centipede too I had trouble keeping my hi-score for Centipede it would reset or sometimes even put the scores out of order e.g might show 50,000 ranked as #1 and 51,000 ranked as #2, in the end I deleted my NVRAM file and haven't had a problem since. Also had similar problem with Asteroids Deluxe and deleting the NVRAM file fixed that as well.
Just for interest sake what is your wife's Hi-Score and do you have a track-ball or just use a mouse.