I never was a big Sega fan. I thought, and still think, that Sonic the Hedgehog is a terrible game. Everything about it rubs me the wrong way, from the character design to the sound effects (god, the sound of all the rings exploding out of you every time you get hit is like nails on a chalkboard), to it not being fun.
OMFG? I totally agree with you? Sonic was a pitiful attempt by sega to out-do mario and it worked for a time, not because sonic was a better game, but because the sonic character was edgier (which delights stupid children to no end) and they invented a fake technology called "blast processing" that made stupid youngsters think the geneis was more powerful than the snes, when actually, the opposite was true. Sonic goes fast, the problem is, he's like controlling a bullet.... a drunk bullet... with one hand. The key to a good platformer is for the controls to be very tight.. something sonic never had. The random, generic monsters and more silly guest characters than a mega man game didn't help either. Sonic isn't showing it's age because it's getting worse, it's just the gimmicky marketing wore off. Sega and it's consoles were all flash and no substance. The general public is real slow to pick up on this, but once they do, they drop you like a sack of bricks. Kind of reminds me of sony actually. Expect to see a similar post about sony 5-10 years from now.
I will say I enjoyed Sonic and the secret rings though... probably the only sonic game I played to the end. It still pales in comparison to a comparable nintendo title though. And that is sega's real issue... they are a poor man's nintendo.
They do/did make great arcade titles though. The reason is they like to make ride-on games and lightgun games. Those games are really simple and don't have to be great, as long as the controls are fun. I think they will do well on the wii because of this.
I don't miss them as a console manufacturer at all. The only decent console they ever made was the dreamcast, and unfortunately, that was too little, too late as the public had already been burned by 3 horrible consoles/console add-ons from sega. (32x, sega cd, sega saturn). Sega sometimes hits the mark, but it is seldom. A mid-level, third-party developer is just about where they always needed to be, so I think their current position is just right for them. Good sega software will always be around, mostly because of their strong arcade presence in japan, which funds their console projects. I don't hate sega by any means, they just were never at the caliber of nintendo.
So no, I don't miss a genesis with it's puny dithered version of Mortal Kombat which required a new controller that people bought because even though the snes version was arcade perfect, it painted the blood grey. I don't miss pleople soing on and on about how the genesis had more sports games when most sports games suck anyway. I don't miss sega coming out with a 200 dollar add-on to the crappy genesis not once, but twice and convicing people it would improve the system when they were just glorified drives that, not unlike the playstation, only added storage capacity and still suffered from inferior graphics. People remember the dreamcast, but they seem to forget about all the crap the poor sega fanboy's had to put up with to get to the dreamcast.