The main advantage of vinyl is that you can put all colors in one and the artwork actually sticks to the cabinet while you paint it. This does two things, one, keeps the edges very nice and crisp (you can mimic overspray if you wish) and it keeps all the colors perfectly registered on the cabinet saving time and headaches of switching and aligning subsequent stencils. Yea, for a touch more you can get thin plastic stencils that you can potentially re-use.. but don't forget, for those to truly work correctly you need to put some kind of adhesive on them anyway to stick them to the cabinet or you'll have tons of overspray and an imprecise final product. After use, you have to deal with cleaning that adhesive off and hope they don't curl up during painting. (Not intending anything negative, but look at the photos of the 'multi use' stencils on the defender within this thread, you clearly see lots of overspray which is the nature of that kind of stencil, not anything the painter did wrong). Add to that, the reality that you're most likely not going to paint two or more of any one game in your lifetime, most people do one game and keep it and the stencils would just get stored somewhere forever anyway. My goal really was to offer a much better quality final product than is currently available on the market.. Paper ones, thin plastic ones etc have been around forever and they are tough to work with (i've done tons of stencilled games over the years using all of them, my technique of using Acetate and Photo mount has been around for a long time when I didn't care for the ones commercially available) no, it's not re-usable, but yes it will look better when you are done and at 60 bucks or so, it's cheap.