I was pulling the chips so I could clean the board. The guy I bought the games from keeps them in a warehouse that might as well just be a tarp supported by sticks, for all the protection it gives his games. The boards were caked with dust & covered in cobwebs; I'd guess it's been in the warehouse for at least 8 years.
As far as the pins being broken before or after I started yanking them, it's hard to say. There's a lot of rust on some of the pins, and they could have just rusted away, and my removing them finished them off.
I did the same thing to my MK boards and had no problems, luckily. It actually runs better than it did before; got rid of some background corruption and general wonkiness.
I seriously doubt my soldering skills are good enough to fix the pins. Although this would be good practice.

I'll probably end up getting another board set.