It's hard to tell from post's, but I'm just curious on the subject and not saying your opinion is wrong or anything.
I've just never heard someone knock the advantage. My Advantage still works solidly and always thought it was a good controller and built pretty heavy and solidly. For me at the time, it was the closest thing to an arcade controller, Big buttons and a ball joystick. I thought everyone else thought this way too, so that's why I am curious on learning someone else's opinion. Maybe I was just lucky, but Hell you've got me so interested that now I'm going to have to take that plate off the bottom to look for white dust.
We are talking about the Advantage and not the Max, right? (The "stupid Pad" and "plastic on plastic" comment is what made me think of this)
And like I said (meant), I wasn't knocking the 2600 controller as a bad controller. It is solid, but the rubber boots did come off (mine after years of use) and my paddles broke pretty quickly when I first got it. One was just a dirty pot, at the time I didn't know that, the other the knob came off shortly after I got it. These are known things to happen. You could probably search the forums and see a comment about it. I've never witnessed, heard someone mention, or seen a post here about the plastic dust on the Advantage or N64 controller. I missed the N64 so it's no wonder I don't know about that, but I thought I would of heard something about the Advantage.
Anyways just curious, the 2600 and NES were the consoles that I used for years and still have. Learning something new about them is always interesting.