I'm not certain if you interpret "rare" to mean "unheard of and will never happen to you", but I don't. I also think you missed the part where I said to moderate your water intake and don't go overboard until you've talked to a doctor.
It's flat out irresponsible to say that something won't hurt him unless you're his doctor, and it's even more so when the potential problem that may be caused is
DEATH! I bring up something you've admitted you've NEVER heard of, and after reading a little on the subject, you feel confident enough to tell us "average" people shouldn't have problems with what you're saying, when you weren't even aware that there COULD be a possibly lethal problem with the advice you're dispensing. Hyponatremia isn't the only issue that could result. Distended bladder. Heard of that too? Can also be caused by excessive water intake. These AREN'T the only 2 things that can happen, so STOP arguing a point because you THINK it's insignificant. You've got
NOTHING to base your ideas on other than your interpretation of "rare" and who you THINK will be affected.
I don't care WHAT you feel the odds are about your advice being possibly lethal or not, the fact that it COULD even happen isn't a debatable issue (and to clarify, "rare" DOES NOT mean "won't ever happen", and "rare" DOES NOT specifiy what level of fitness will be affected) , whether you "feel confident" about it or not. It DOES happen, it COULD happen, and unless you're a doctor, DON'T tell people to increase their intake of ANYTHING because "there's no way it could hurt them".
The first thing that should EVER be recommended for someone is to talk to their doctor and get specifics about what their doctor believes is ok for them to undertake. Exercises, reps, form, FINE! Anything else, you might as well tell him it's ok to fiddle around his monitor and don't even worry about that anode cap. After all, it's "rare" that he'd ever kill himself
