The control panel is made of MDF shelving (has a nice curved edge on one side). The silver is actually metallic cabinet/contact paper that I picked up at Walmart. It has a peel stick backing and is fairly thick, and slick on the surface. It gives it a nice look, and was easy to put on.
As far as getting the flaking paint off (mine was about 50% gone), I soaked it in a tub of hot water for a few hours. A large quantity came off then. For the harder stuff I used a pain scraper and Gunk-off or Goo-gone (can't remember exactly). I used that to remove the adhesive left from the vinyl stickers on the cabinet once I removed them with a heat gun and elbow grease.
My control panel is about 1" longer than the original, so I had to move the wooden panel/glass support back. The original smoked/slightly mirrored glass that was in there fit in this new spot perfectly (I didn't even consider it when I moved the wood), so now the monitor is totally blacked out. This isn't the front glass (which now is too large and would need about 1/2" removed off the bottom), but the glass that the game was reflected on and picked up the side art to give it a 3-d effect. I used a combination of black poster board and magic marker to blacken the monitor. I have some new side/marquee art I am working on that will give it the original look but still be custom, having it say Omegarcade instead.
Brad
