Can I compile Mame 106 for x64?

[ID4]

Hi!

I´m trying to compile Mame Source 106 for x64 architecture, I´m using the same dev tools that used for ArcadeMAME 106 (http://www.mamedev.org/tools/previous-20070810.html)

When I remove try to compile with mingw-make32.exe using "PTR64=1" in the makefile, I get this error:

Compiling src/windows/winddraw.c...
Compiling src/windows/winmain.c...
src/windows/winmain.c: In function `exception_filter':
src/windows/winmain.c:431: error: structure has no member named `Rax'
src/windows/winmain.c:432: error: structure has no member named `Rbx'
src/windows/winmain.c:433: error: structure has no member named `Rcx'
src/windows/winmain.c:434: error: structure has no member named `Rdx'
src/windows/winmain.c:436: error: structure has no member named `Rsi'
src/windows/winmain.c:437: error: structure has no member named `Rdi'
src/windows/winmain.c:438: error: structure has no member named `Rbp'
src/windows/winmain.c:439: error: structure has no member named `Rsp'
src/windows/winmain.c:441: error: structure has no member named `R8'
src/windows/winmain.c:442: error: structure has no member named `R9'
src/windows/winmain.c:443: error: structure has no member named `R10'
src/windows/winmain.c:444: error: structure has no member named `R11'
src/windows/winmain.c:446: error: structure has no member named `R12'
src/windows/winmain.c:447: error: structure has no member named `R13'
src/windows/winmain.c:448: error: structure has no member named `R14'
src/windows/winmain.c:449: error: structure has no member named `R15'
src/windows/winmain.c:403: warning: unused variable `code_start'
src/windows/winmain.c:403: warning: unused variable `code_size'
mingw32-make.exe: *** [obj/mamepp/windows/winmain.o] Error 1

Any help plese?

[headkaze]

Can you compile vanilla MAME x64?

[ID4]

Vanilla Mame x64? What is this?

Using mi standar mingw compiler that I used to compile ArcadeMAME106 32 bits, but using PTR64=1 in the makefile, after a while, get this:

Compiling src/windows/winddraw.c...
Compiling src/windows/winmain.c...
src/windows/winmain.c: In function `exception_filter':
src/windows/winmain.c:431: error: structure has no member named `Rax'
src/windows/winmain.c:432: error: structure has no member named `Rbx'
src/windows/winmain.c:433: error: structure has no member named `Rcx'
src/windows/winmain.c:434: error: structure has no member named `Rdx'
src/windows/winmain.c:436: error: structure has no member named `Rsi'
src/windows/winmain.c:437: error: structure has no member named `Rdi'
src/windows/winmain.c:438: error: structure has no member named `Rbp'
src/windows/winmain.c:439: error: structure has no member named `Rsp'
src/windows/winmain.c:441: error: structure has no member named `R8'
src/windows/winmain.c:442: error: structure has no member named `R9'
src/windows/winmain.c:443: error: structure has no member named `R10'
src/windows/winmain.c:444: error: structure has no member named `R11'
src/windows/winmain.c:446: error: structure has no member named `R12'
src/windows/winmain.c:447: error: structure has no member named `R13'
src/windows/winmain.c:448: error: structure has no member named `R14'
src/windows/winmain.c:449: error: structure has no member named `R15'
src/windows/winmain.c:403: warning: unused variable `code_start'
src/windows/winmain.c:403: warning: unused variable `code_size'
mingw32-make.exe: *** [obj/mamepp/windows/winmain.o] Error 1

So I installed Mame Compiler 64 1.17 and try for 64 bits, get this:

Compiling Mame64...
Using Parameters  MSVC_BUILD=1 PTR64=1
mkdir.exe obj
mkdir.exe obj/mame
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/adsp2100
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/alph8201
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/arm
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/arm7
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/asap
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/ccpu
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/dsp32
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/dsp56k
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/e132xs
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/g65816
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/h6280
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/h83002
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/hd6309
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/i386
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/i8039
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/i8051
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/i8085
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/i86
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/i8x41
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/i960
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/jaguar
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/konami
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/m37710
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/m6502
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/m6800
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/m68000
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/m6805
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/m6809
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/mc68hc11
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/mips
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/nec
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/pic16c5x
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/powerpc
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/r3000
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/rsp
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/s2650
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/se3208
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/sh2
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/sharc
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/spc700
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/t11
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/tms32010
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/tms32025
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/tms32031
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/tms32051
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/tms34010
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/tms9900
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/upd7810
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/v60
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/v810
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/z180
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/z80
mkdir.exe obj/mame/cpu/z8000
mkdir.exe obj/mame/debug
mkdir.exe obj/mame/drivers
mkdir.exe obj/mame/expat
mkdir.exe obj/mame/machine
mkdir.exe obj/mame/sndhrdw
mkdir.exe obj/mame/sound
mkdir.exe obj/mame/vidhrdw
mkdir.exe obj/mame/windows
mkdir.exe obj/mame/zlib
Compiling src/artwork.c...
mingw32-make: *** [obj/mame/artwork.o] Error -101
Finished!
0 Hours 0 Minutes and 11 Seconds Elapsed.

Altrough, If I use Mame compiler 64 1.17 with the same source and compile for 32 bits, It compiles perfect.

What is the problem? :-(

[headkaze]

Did you follow the instructions here?

[ID4]

Yes I read it.

As I said, I used my "standar" mingw32 for Mame 106, as described in http://www.mamedev.org/tools/previous-20070810.html. With this I get ArcadeMAME 106 for 32 Bits compiled without any problems.

Now, I used Mame Compiler 64 1.17 and GET ArcadeMAME 106 compiled for 32 Bits but need to edit the makefile and uncheck
"-Werror -Wall" and "-Wno-unused-functions"

#-------------------------------------------------
# compile and linking flags
#-------------------------------------------------

CFLAGS = -std=gnu89 -Isrc -Isrc/includes -Isrc/$(MAMEOS)

ifdef SYMBOLS
CFLAGS += -O0 -Wall -Wno-unused -g
else
CFLAGS += -DNDEBUG \
   $(ARCH) -O3 -fno-strict-aliasing \
#   -Werror -Wall \
   -Wall \
   -Wno-sign-compare \
#   -Wno-unused-functions \
   -Wpointer-arith \
   -Wbad-function-cast \
   -Wcast-align \
   -Wstrict-prototypes \
   -Wundef \
   -Wformat-security \
   -Wwrite-strings \
   -Wdeclaration-after-statement
endif

With this, Mame Compiler 64 1.17 compiles ArcadeMAME 106 perfectly without any options selected in "Compile Options".

But if try to compile it for 64 Bits "Compile options: 64 Bits processor", It fails here:

Compiling Mame64...
Using Parameters  MSVC_BUILD=1 PTR64=1
Compiling src/artwork.c...
mingw32-make: *** [obj/mame/artwork.o] Error -101
Finished!
0 Hours 0 Minutes and 6 Seconds Elapsed.

[headkaze]

"Vanilla MAME" is an unmodified version of MAME. Can you compile that for x64?

You say you followed the instructions so I can safely assume you have the same version of MinGW I linked to.

[ID4]

Hi!

I tried "vanilla" Mame 106 x64 with "64 bits processor" and "Disable Warnings as Error", result:

Compiling src/artwork.c...
mingw32-make: *** [obj/mame/artwork.o] Error -101
Finished!
0 Hours 0 Minutes and 31 Seconds Elapsed.

The same problem

Mame Compiler 64 MinGW:

C:\MinGW\bin>mingw32-make --version
GNU Make 3.81
Copyright (C) 2006  Free Software Foundation, Inc.
This is free software; see the source for copying conditions.
There is NO warranty; not even for MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A
PARTICULAR PURPOSE.

This program built for i686-pc-mingw32

My MinGW:

C:\mingw32\bin>mingw32-make --version
GNU Make 3.80
Copyright (C) 2002  Free Software Foundation, Inc.
This is free software; see the source for copying conditions.
There is NO warranty; not even for MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A
PARTICULAR PURPOSE.

[headkaze]

Sorry I only just realised you were compiling MAME 106. That's a pretty old version of MAME. Any reason why you are compiling such an old version?

On the Mame Compiler webpage did you read the part called "Older Versions of MAME"?

[ID4]

Hi!

Yeah, As I said, I´m the author of "ArcadeMAME106", I just finished the final version and compiled it perfectly as ever for 32 Bits using the tools described in mamedev "Older Versions of MAME".

The problem is that I want to compile it for x64 too before of publish ArcadeMAME106 final version.

Can you help me? 

[Haze]

the 64-bit option was first added as an experimental dev option around that point.. but not 'official' until around 0.120 IIRC..

it probably required a bunch of extra tricks to compile it, and likely doesn't even work once compiled for a fair chunk of drivers because a lot of code wasn't even 64-bit safe at that point.. it might even end up slower than the 32-bit binary because I think at that point there was still a fair bit of x86 assembly in certain areas of MAME that would have to be disabled in the 64-bit build because there was no x64 equivalent.

the code has improved a LOT since 0.106 in such areas... this isn't like the UME situation where it is considered 'experimental' but works 100% fine, it was a case of 'we know it's horribly broken, so broken we're not even making it an official option at this point because we don't want to deal with the reports'

[ID4]

Mnnn

So, say goodbye to an x64 version? 

Anyway Mame106 is fast, even on old machines, maybe an 64 bits version is not necesary ...

If I "touch" again the Mame sources to make an "ArcadeMAME", It be the last or a least one of the last, and will be based in GroovyMAME.

I will finish the documentation of ArcadeMAME 106 and publish it, It will take some days ...