Sadly, this game would suck.
Why, you ask? Glad you did...i shall tell you

1) Within 1 day of opening, you'd already have the "Elite Beta Testers" ganging up and killing off all the people who actually paid for the game in a store. Then, they'd be telling you how elite they were cuz, they are Beta Testers.
2) Within 2 weeks, groups of high school kids with nothing else to do with their shallow, excitement-free middle America lives will have drawn the line between the casual players and the kids with nothing better to do so they play all day long. The defenseless n00b has no chance. "Join my Gang!", "Tryouts for My Gang at 5pm", are all you hear.....inter-gang killing runs rampant.
3) Within 3 weeks, someone will have figured out a way to set their video card to a certain color/driver combination that would allow them to shoot through walls and always get headshots.

4) Within a month, the servers would be so overloaded nobody would be able to log on. The company making the game will blame Al Qaeda.
5) Within two months the only people doing well are the power-mad guys who want to play the game professionally and compete in tournaments. Naturally these groups would all be guys from Sweden or Russia, who have reverse-engineered the code and have learned how to exploit every flaw within it.
etc, etc
