Thanks for all of the additional thoughts guys. Definitely gives me some stuff to think about.
Mainly, I guess I was planning to buy a 360 and then a few of the game titles like Namco Musuem Virtual Arcade, The Sega Collection, Konami classics, etc, and then mod the XBOX enough to be able to put the games on a harddrive with a nice frontend so that you can select which game to play. I do want to do a real MAME setup someday, so I'll leave all of the emulation stuff for that project. I wasn't planning to go online with this setup. And my initial plan was to just buy a nice 24" LCD monitor to hook it up to. Although I guess most of the old stuff is 4:3?
I'll have to do some more research on the controllers. I would like this to be as close to a real arcade experience as possible, so I'm not sure if that means hacked controllers, or the street fighter sticks. Which of those would be better for controlling the collection of games I am interested in?
If anyone has any 360 projects they'd like to share here, I'm definitely curious.
Thanks again.
I put a 360 in one of my cabinets, as well as a PC for Mame. I got HarumaN to hack a couple controllers up for me, so that I can use them both on a PC and 360. I used a KVM (usb and vga) switch to bounce back and forth between the two, and it worked pretty flawlessly. The switch was mounted on the inside of the coin door, so when I wanted to switch it I just reach in there and press the little toggle button.
Having a 360 in a cabinet really lends well to a plethora of newer games that fit well with a proper arcade control panel. Games like Super Street Fighter 4, Pacman:CE, Puzzle Fighter HD, Castle Crashers, even some of the re-released japanese SHMUPS and Shooters.
My cabinet used an 19" 4:3 LCD, but the lack of Widescreen support for these games didn't really bother me too much, as they're made to scale down to the screen size.
(something about playing the new Street Fighters feels right in 4:3 mode)
The downside to having a 360 in there is that there is no easy way of hacking the analog sticks of a 360 controller. So games that solely rely on the analog sticks are unplayable (Geometry Wars, Mutant Storm, etc). But there are a lot of games that use the Dpad. I'm not sure if the new NBA Jam uses the Dpad, but if it does, that'd be sweet too.
One other thing I wanted to mention was the online ability. I really loved connecting online with my 360, having score leader-boards, playing online against people. It really changes the solo experience at home, into a more arcade world-stage one.
Here's a
link to my old Galaxbox machine. I don't have it anymore, since I sold it to a friend of mine. But I will eventually build another cabinet (perhaps based on the Vewlix design) that will definitely have the same setup.