MS+ has a VERY short throw. U360's have extremely long throws. The Happ is the more natural arcade type bat stick. If SF is the game you are most concerned with, I'd go Happ...plus it is the cheapest. However, it's when you throw other games into the equation where it gets complicated. I noticed that the MS+ was not very good on certain games, especially Robotron. Also, it is far from idiotproof if having guests play is an issue. I currently have U360's. They work great, but take some getting used to. Pacman type games are difficult because of the long throw, but overall it is very versatile and idiotproof.