Basically, this button wasn't triggering the microswitch with consistency. You'd press the button, and sometimes it would stick in the down position. Other times it wouldn't trip the switch; like, you'd press and instead of feeling that point of resistance when the switch triggers, there'd just be nothing. The first few times I'd open the CP up, wiggle things around from the inside, and it'd work again for a while.
I already replaced it; I bought more buttons than I needed when I made my order. But I was more curious if others had this happen. Namco probably has the right of it and I will give his suggestion a try and see if it operates smoothly after that.
If not, well, it's $2. It'll obviously set my retirement plans back by a few years, but...