Replacing the joystick switches helped - a lot - but you still require a lot of effort to move it around.  It's too stiff.  I suspect that this joystick is acutally two joysticks the previous owner stuck together, and it's not quite right.
Well, I found two problems with the joys I had in there, and that's why I was having to wail on the joys.
1) they're four way joysticks.  Explains why I couldn't hit diagonals.  Funny I didn't notice this before.
2) the actuator was broken.  Slightly chipped, it lowered it enough so it wasn't hitting the switches.
Swapped it out for a couple 8 way leafs and viola!  Nice game play.
The only problem is they're Wico leafs, and you can't get the switches any more.  I broke one, but luckily had another broken one I could use for parts.  But man, they sure are smooth.
Monitor has developed a severe problem, but Bob Roberts says a cap kit should help it.  Now I just have to pull the board and count the caps.